top of page
DFA-Tax-Investigations-HMRC-Individuals.webp

Facing an HMRC Investigation?

Expert support when it matters most.

When HMRC calls

For most people, a letter from HMRC requesting information or formally opening an investigation into your tax affairs arrives without warning.

 

One day everything is normal.  The next, you're staring at correspondence that raises questions you don't fully understand, about records that may go back years.

​

It's a disorientating experience, even for those who have done nothing wrong.

HMRC has broad powers to enquire into personal and business tax returns, request financial records, open formal investigations under Code of Practice 8 or Code of Practice 9, and pursue criminal prosecution.

 

The scope of what they can examine is wide.  The timeline can stretch over months, sometimes years. And the financial exposure, including potential penalties and interest, can be substantial.

 

What makes this particularly difficult is that most people have no prior experience of the process.  You may not know what HMRC is entitled to ask for, what your obligations are, how to respond without accidentally making things worse, or when a figure they've calculated is wrong and challengeable.

 

These are specialist matters.  Without proper support, it's easy to be overwhelmed by the process or worse, to accept an outcome that isn't correct.

What You're Up Against

The information burden

HMRC can request years of documentation and presenting it in a way that supports your position requires more than handing over files.

The technical complexity

How income is categorised, how assets are treated, how business and personal finances interact are areas where honest mistakes happen, and where the distinction between an error and a deliberate omission matters enormously.

The pressure to settle

There is often pressure to agree a figure. That settlement may not reflect what you actually owe.

Disproportionate penalties

How you engage with the process, and how your position is presented, can directly affect the penalties applied.

HMRC investigations are methodical and can stretch over months, sometimes years. Officers are looking for discrepancies, testing the accuracy of what's been declared. They won't always be right. But the burden of demonstrating that falls to you.

Where Forensic Accounting makes a difference

When HMRC opens an investigation, the numbers they work from aren't always accurate. Records get misinterpreted, assumptions get made, and figures reconstructed from incomplete information get presented as fact.

​

A forensic accountant's job is to examine that work and where it's wrong, to demonstrate it clearly and credibly. That means going through the underlying records in detail, identifying where HMRC's position doesn't hold up, and producing independent analysis that can be presented formally in correspondence, in meetings, or before a tribunal if necessary.

​

It also means ensuring your own position is properly documented and presented in a way that makes your case as clearly as possible.

​

Having a forensic accountant engaged early also serves a protective function meaning that responses to HMRC are considered and accurate and don't inadvertently introduce new problems into a situation that's already under scrutiny.

The situations we handle

Not every investigation looks the same. The type you're facing shapes everything about how it needs to be handled. Deans Forensic Accounting works across the full range, including:

​​​

✔ Self-assessment enquiries: where HMRC questions the accuracy of a personal tax return

✔ Business records checks: where trading records are examined for completeness and consistency

✔ VAT investigations: where the treatment of transactions or the calculation of VAT liability is disputed

✔ Code of Practice 8 investigations: serious cases involving suspected tax avoidance

✔ Code of Practice 9 investigations: the most serious category, involving suspected deliberate fraud, where HMRC offers a formal disclosure process

✔ Employer compliance reviews: covering PAYE, National Insurance, and benefits in kind

✔ Discovery assessments: where HMRC raises a charge for a year it believes was under-declared

✔ Unwinding tax schemes. Where historic tax schemes are now viewed as tax evasion and need to be unwound. 

 

Whatever the nature of the investigation, we're here to offer independent, credible analysis that gives you the strongest possible position.

Why Deans Forensic Accounting

Specialist Expertise. Independent Analysis. A Clear Head When You Need One.

​

Deans Forensic Accounting specialises in forensic accounting and financial investigation. 

​

The team holds professional accreditations from the ICAEW, the Academy of Experts, and the National Institute of Forensic Accountants (the bodies that set the standard for rigorous, independent forensic work). That independence is what gives the analysis its credibility, whether in correspondence with HMRC, through a formal disclosure process, or before a tribunal.

​

Clients get direct access to senior expertise throughout and where the process feels complex or the language impenetrable, Deans communicates in plain English, so you always know where you stand.

DFA-Discuss-Your-Case.webp

Let’s discuss your case

Need expert forensic accounting support? Get in touch for a free initial consultation.

bottom of page