top of page
DFA-Tax-Investigations-HMRC.webp

Tax investigations & HMRC

For when the case turns on the financial evidence

When HMRC enquiries escalate

Most HMRC enquiries begin with a letter. For many people, that letter goes to their accountant, a response is prepared, and the matter is resolved.

​

But some enquiries don't resolve but escalate into detailed investigations, requests for extensive financial records, or formal challenges to the accuracy of what has been reported.

 

At that point, the situation has moved beyond compliance. It has become a legal matter, and it needs to be treated as one. That is the point at which it tends to reach a solicitor's desk.

Beyond compliance 

When a matter reaches a solicitor or us as specialist forensic accountants, the question is now about constructing a defence.

​​

A tax adviser's role is to manage the compliance process and to ensure returns are accurate, disclosures are made, and correspondence is handled. That remains important. But once the enquiry has escalated to the point where legal or our representation is required, the financial analysis needs to do something different.

​

It needs to establish what the true position actually is.

​

Not what was reported and not what the client believes. But what a detailed, independent review of the financial records actually shows clearly enough that it can be explained to HMRC, relied upon in correspondence, and if necessary, defended in a formal hearing.

What forensic input brings that a tax adviser can't

A tax adviser works from what has been reported. A forensic accountant works from what the records actually show and that's not always the same thing.

​

Where financial information is incomplete, inconsistent, or open to challenge, forensic analysis reconstructs the position from the ground up, independently, without a prior relationship with the client, and without an interest in the outcome.

​

That independence is what gives the analysis its weight and converts it from being a set of statements into a defensible strategic and structured position.

The situations we handle

Forensic input is typically required when an HMRC enquiry has moved beyond a straightforward compliance response. 

That includes:

 

✔ Detailed investigations into past income, transactions, or tax returns

✔ Cases where financial records are incomplete, inconsistent, or require reconstruction

✔ Matters involving undisclosed income or assets

✔ Enquiries covering multiple years where the position needs to be established clearly

✔ Situations where HMRC's assumptions need to be tested and responded to independently

 

If you are unsure whether a matter requires forensic input, an initial conversation will usually make that clear.

Trusted by legal professionals across the UK

"Richard was instructed to provide expert opinion in relation to a criminal investigation... My general assessment of Richard was that of someone with a vast amount of practical and current experience. Richard placed significant emphasis on confidentiality which, in the context of my criminal investigation, was vital."

Michael Walters - Senior Trading Standards Officer, TRADING STANDARDS

"Richard was instructed to provide expert opinion in relation to a criminal investigation... My general assessment of Richard was that of someone with a vast amount of practical and current experience. Richard placed significant emphasis on confidentiality which, in the context of my criminal investigation, was vital."

Michael Walters - Senior Trading Standards Officer, TRADING STANDARDS

"Richard was instructed to provide expert opinion in relation to a criminal investigation... My general assessment of Richard was that of someone with a vast amount of practical and current experience. Richard placed significant emphasis on confidentiality which, in the context of my criminal investigation, was vital."

Michael Walters - Senior Trading Standards Officer, TRADING STANDARDS

academy-of-experts-logo.gif

Accredited Member, Academy of Experts

ICAEW-logo.gif

Regulated by the ICAEW

36

Years of forensic accounting experience

100+

Sectors covered and experienced

100+

Business valuations completed

100%

Record of meeting agreed deadlines

DFA-Discuss-Your-Case.webp

Ready to Discuss a Matter?

If you have an HMRC investigation where forensic input may assist, we are happy to have an initial conversation before any instruction is confirmed.

​

That conversation is confidential, carries no obligation, and is focused on whether we can genuinely help with the matter in hand.

​

Request a Preliminary Case Discussion

Request a preliminary case discussion or discuss a current matter confidentially

How to pick the right forensic accountant

Our free guide walks you through exactly what the court expects of an expert witness and the questions every solicitor should ask before making an appointment.

bottom of page